I use cornstarch as my thickener when I make pastry cream. No matter how long I cook the cream I still get that "cornstarch" taste. Any help? My recipe is 1 Cup of milk, 2 egg yolks, 2 ounces of sugar and 1 tablespoon of cornstarch. butter and vanilla.

  • 1
    Do you add the starch and the yolks at the same time?
    – Stephie
    Mar 17 '17 at 14:34
  • Yes. I add the starch to the eggs with the sugar. The milk I warm up then temper it in.
    – Lucia
    Mar 20 '17 at 18:00

I would argue that it is the gentler methods like Doug suggested which create problems. They are intended for eggs only custards, not eggs-and-starch. If you use them, you risk that your mixture doesn't get hot enough. Then your starch stays uncooked, and your eggs' starch-digesting enzymes stay intact and can liquefy everything.

If you use either starch only, or a mixture of eggs and starch, your custard has to boil. I slurry the starch with a bit of the milk, never tried it with the eggs. Then add the slurry to the almost-simmering milk (which already contains sugar and flavors), and pour in the tempered eggs afterwards if using them. From the time the starch hits the liquid, you have to stir constantly or you risk burnt bottom, so you don't want to do it too early, but if you do it too late, the stream of slurry will start gelatinizing before it has been dispersed in the milk, and will clump. So, do it just before simmering, or if it has started to simmer, take it off the heat, mix it there, then back on the heat.

After you have the slurry well mixed in, you simply stir slowly until after it has blubbed. You will notice a moment when it goes from liquid to thick, this is when the starch starts gelatinizing. Less than a minute later you should see the boil bubbles, which are very large and slow-forming in the viscous liquid. That's the time to take it off the heat, your starch is fully cooked and will not taste chalky. If you are serving it for a fussy occasion, it makes sense to pass it through a sieve to catch stray clumps of starch or egg protein, but I usually don't bother.

If you were trying to keep the eggs from overcooking, that's impossible. Eggs overcook at around 87 C, while starch gelatinizes around 96 C. Also, the yolks will eat up your starch after 24 to 48 hours if not heated well. So you cannot keep the taste of a starchless custard if you use starch. That's not a problem texture-wise, since the starch takes care of the texture and you don't get the corning or whey exudate associated with overcooked egg custards.


I'm not 100% on your method so hope this doesn't come across patronising or like I'm teaching you to suck eggs (pun intended 😊).

  1. Cornflour and sugar should be mixed together first. This is because cornflour is a micro fine powder, which means it's likes to clump.
  2. Then the above should be added to the eggs and whisked till foamy, that'll stop the corn flour feeling. As it'll be completely evenly dispersed.
  3. Now get your milk or cream up to a simmer. Take off the heat and pour half over your egg mix while stiring to stop it scrambling. Pour this back into the pan and continue to stir for ... say 5 mins? On a gentle heat until thick.
  4. Transfer into a cool container, and cool quickly by stiring while container is partially immersed in an ice bath to stop it going lumpy.

If it tastes starchy it's possible you're putting to much in. Baring in mind 2 yolks will easily set a cup of milk (creme brulee) you could try halving your starch to see if you get a better end result. This depends a lot on your intended use.

  • Thank you so much! Incredibly helpful. I think I will play around with the quantity of cornstarch.
    – Lucia
    Mar 20 '17 at 18:01

This is very helpful. Thank you. I'll test the idea of bringing it to a boil. I very much dislike that chalky aftertaste. Have you ever worked with potato starch? I stumbled upon this alternative but not yet tried. Thanks again.

  • You should delete this answer and instead vote / accept an actual answer. Leaving, what you have put as an answer, as a comment to the related question. If you don't it'll get removed by a mod anyway and likely down voted by someone, never ideal.
    – Doug
    Mar 20 '17 at 19:10

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.