I occasionally make homemade pizza using pre-made dough (similar to this), however I can never seem to get the dough cooked properly all the way through. It ends up with nicely done edges but an underdone middle, or a properly cooked middle but overdone edges (occasionally I get lucky and get overdone edges with an underdone middle too).

Generally for cooking it I follow the instructions on the packaging, about 15 minutes at about 450F. It is cooked on an upside-down cookie sheet.

What can I do to get a pizza that is the proper done-ness throughout?

  • 1
    For the product you linked to, the instructions say bake at 400-425F depending on pan type. That could be why you are not getting the desired results. – Debbie M. Feb 27 '18 at 1:57
  • @DebbieM. That isn't the brand I normally use, just an example of the type of product I'm using. Generally I get whatever the off brand is at the store I am shopping at. – diego Feb 27 '18 at 2:01
  • 1
    I cheat : slice.seriouseats.com/2010/09/… ; cook the dough in a cast iron pan on the stovetop, flip it, cook the other side, flip again and add toppings, then slide under the broiler. If I'm making a bunch, I'll just cook the crust 'til it's showing color on each side, then move them to a sheet pan so people can top them, and finish it in the oven (baking, not broiling, but you can broil at the end if you want) – Joe Feb 27 '18 at 4:24
  1. Get a pizza stone. It is important to preheat the stone with the oven. Put it in the oven before you begin to preheat, if your not in a hurry...let the stone and the oven hold at temperature for a while before you put the pizza on it. The stone will radiate heat into your dough evenly. Stones are 'better' than metal (like a cookie sheet) because they release the heat into the dough 'more evenly' If you have a 'pizza pan' putting that on the stone will work well also.

  2. Completely preheat your oven. Many electric ovens use the broiler coil (on top) to heat the oven to the desired temperature faster, if you attempt to bake your pizza during the pre-heat stage the top is likely to cook faster than the dough. You may eyeball your pizza as done because the top 'looks' ready, when the dough is not yet finished.

  3. One of the common culprits in an 'underdone' middle is that liquid has soaked into the dough causing it to cook more slowly. If your sauce is too thin you might want to thicken it up some. Also, spreading a thin coat of soft (not melted) butter over the top will form a barrier to prevent the liquid in the sauce from soaking in. Finally, you might try putting the grated cheese on first and then spreading the sauce over that. As the cheese melts and the sauce warms it will settle into (approximately) the expected layers, but if the sauce has been kept from the dough for a few minutes it will not soak in as much.

If you aren't satisfied with these results then you might try:

  1. Get an oven thermometer. The temperature actually in your oven will vary from 'the dial'. It's expected, just know what you're actually getting. You want your oven to be 'very hot' (professional pizza ovens will range from 600°F - 900°F) your home oven is unlikely to get 'that' hot but 450°F should be close enough to do the job.

  2. As a last resort... par bake the crust. Put the un-covered crust in the oven for a few (5ish) minutes first, pull it, then top it and return it to the oven.

I hope you find something here to help with your pizza woes.

  • 2
    +1 for "hold the stove and stone at temp for a while. There is a reason why recipes usually say preheat oven at the beginning of a recipe. A truly preheated oven is one where all the internal components have reached the target temp, not just the air. This allows the oven to spring back to temp when the door is opened. The time recommended by most experienced cooks chefs for pre-heating most ovens is a full 30 minutes. – Escoce Feb 28 '18 at 13:30
  • butter on a pizza? that's a first.. – Agos Mar 1 '18 at 11:23
  • @Agos, actually I first saw it from Alton Brown years ago. There are even a number of pizza places where you can taste the butter (that is perhaps too much, but that is a matter of taste) – Cos Callis Mar 1 '18 at 14:23

Try preheating your cookie sheet before laying the uncooked pizza on it, otherwise it may act as a heatsink/insulator until it reaches the right temperature, delaying the cooking (particularly near its center of mass). I like using a piece of parchment paper to make transferring the dough between my tray and the counter easier.

  • A "typical" cookie sheet won't have enough heat capacity to make any difference if it is preheated or not. You need a pizza stone for that to work. – MaxW Feb 26 '18 at 22:44
  • Fair enough, it just seems like a very easy change to make that may solve their problem. IME it makes a difference when cooking frozen pizza. Can't say I've noticed any difference when it comes to my own dough. – mech Feb 26 '18 at 22:46
  • 1
    @mech : it might not affect how much it's cooked through, but it will affect the browning of the bottom if you're using a shiny pan. I do this when I'm baking empanadas, and it makes a dramatic difference – Joe Feb 27 '18 at 4:19

I have a pizza stone, which makes a big difference. But I don't always use it because I have a pizza pan that's bigger than the stone. There are a few things you can try:

  • Roll the base thinner, so it cooks through quicker. When rolling I tend to flour quite heavily, which reduces the amount the sauce soaks in.

  • Cook directly on the oven shelf, with a baking tray underneath to catch anything that falls off. This seems to work better for ready-made/par-baked bases. I've never tried parbaking a homemade base but think it would be tricky to get the texture right.

  • If you like a lot of sauce, heat it just before topping the pizza. This will help the temperature of the base come up quicker.

  • Don't mess around putting the pizza in -- I've seen people open the oven, walk across the kitchen to fetch the food, position it just perfectly, change their mind about the shelf height, then get round to closing the door. Instead, put the shelf near the top before you preheat, and have the pizza in one hand while you open the door with the other, or at least within reach.

A good preheat is important for something that cooks so quickly, even if your oven doesn't boost the preheat with the grill (broiler) element. I turn the oven on before rolling out/stretching, so it's been preheated for some time when I put the topped pizza in (especially as my small person likes to help withe the topping so it takes a while). This means that all the metal in the oven is up to temperature when it goes in. Note that I don't preheat the pan, as I stretch the base to fill it, then top the pizza on the base -- it's a bit unwieldy otherwise.

Cooking two pizzas on two shelves makes things much harder -- that's partly why I use my (rectangular) tray instead of my stone, and make one big pizza.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.