Readiing a previous question regarding determining the accuracy of oven temperature I wanted to comment/ask more on the topic. My GE Profile wall oven is 17 years old, its electronic board was replaced a few years back and all seemed fine until recently. I have two oven thermometers which give varied results as much as 50 degrees off. I have noticed that my oven does seem to get more accurate at higher temperatures. Set at 350 I know it is less than 300, set at 390 I seem to get close to 350, set at 475 for pizza baking on a stone (which is always in the oven) and the crust bakes just fine. Has anyone experienced a "sliding scale" for accuracy? Anything I can do?

  • Welcome to Seasoned Advice! ;-) Could plu please edit your question and copy-paste the original and post maybe a picture of where the T° gauges are so we have a bit more background? – Fabby Aug 19 '18 at 16:03
  • Your assumption that you have any accuracy at all is suspect because you state that you have two thermometers that read different temperatures. Begin with one oven thermometer, calibrate it to be sure it is reading accurately, then use it to measure the temperature at various points. – moscafj Aug 19 '18 at 17:23
  • All your temperatures are in ºF I assume? it would be nice to just clarify that in your question. – Luciano Aug 21 '18 at 9:26

While I am unsure about the 'sliding scale' you mention I do know that there is something you can do about it. A while back I discovered you can calibrate your thermostat. I couldn't find (quickly anyway) a good video example for the GE Profile, but did find two good GE examples.

Specifically I would suggest finding your particular owners manual (most of them are available online as a PDF for download anymore)

As @moscafj points out if you are using two thermometers which are not in agreement you may want to acquire a new one and treat it as "right" for the purpose of calibrating the rest (or figure out which one is the odd one out and throw it away...)

Some additional notes:

  1. Your pizza stone is likely acting as a heat sink (as it should) making it's behavior more consistent than if you were not using one, this would tend to 'explain away' the sliding scale theory.
  2. You need to be conscience of how often you are opening your oven door. This will have the effect of allowing far more heat escape than most people are aware of. If you are frequently opening the door to check the temperature you are possibly doing more harm than you know. This, too, could explain your observed sliding scale, at least in part.

I strongly suspect the oven isn't heating up as quickly as you think, especially if you keep opening it to measure.

With either a dial type oven thermometer (not very accurate or precise but cheap and you can leave it in there to read through the glass) or a flexible thermocouple threaded through the door seal you can read the temperature without opening the door, and see when it has stopped rising. This is likely to be longer than you think. Keep monitoring for 10-20 minutes after it thinks it's hot and you'll see what I mean. (Both links just to the first example on amazon, not specific recommendations).

This doesn't matter for many foods, but for things that cook hot and fast, it really throws the timing.

When it comes to calibrating, boiling water is easy to check, but anything hotter is hard to pin down. If your thermometer is suitable for immersion, test it against boiling water and see what you get (if you live at high altitude you may need to take this into account).

  • This was going to be a comment on the other answer but there was too much additional material even before I added the links – Chris H Aug 20 '18 at 6:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.