The book that came with my bread maker machine has bread ingredients and quantities in the back but I note that they aren't very consistent in terms of quantities. Take a look at this sourdough:

sourdough bread machine recipe table

I note that the 1.5lb loaf uses the same amount of sugar as a 1lb loaf, but a 2lb loaf uses 3x the amount of sugar as a 1lb loaf

I'm hence wondering if I should use 2tbs of sugar, this being the halfway point between the 1lb loaf's 1 tbsp and the 2lb loaf's 3tbsp?

Similarly they all use the same amount of yeast; does that seem right? By that pattern I could make a tonne of sourdough using only 1/3tsp of yeast! :)

  • The real puzzler for me is the flour. Firstly, I would expect that of all ingredients to be proportional to the desired final weight, and secondly it uses metric units when the desired final weights are given in imperial. Sep 23, 2018 at 7:56
  • British manufacturer too! Probably a half-in-Europe-half-out thing!
    – Caius Jard
    Sep 23, 2018 at 8:00
  • I'd suggest picking up a bread machine book, a published one, which will have much better tested recipes than the booklet. We like Hensperger, but I don't know if she's available in Britian/metric.
    – FuzzyChef
    Sep 24, 2018 at 2:52

2 Answers 2


Mine has only 2 sizes but also has some nonlinearity. You see it with the water as well (in yours and mine). Things like the rate of temperature change, and therefore the rate of rising, will depend on the total quantity, and some change in the proportions of the ingredients will offset that. Yeast multiplies, and a pseudo-sourdough with very little yeast to start with relies on slowly but surely growing the yeast (if you take it to extremes you end up with a true sourdough from wild yeast, with a tiny bit of cultured yeast). So you probably don't have a typo, and can trust the recipe, at least to start with.

Feel free to experiment; you may prefer the result. I use around 1/3 the stated salt and 1/2 the sugar, for example. The rise and texture aren't very different, but I used to find the bread tasted salty (then sweet if I didn't also reduce the sugar).


There are really too different reasons.

First recipes do not have some super exact proportions which must be accurate to 1 part in a 1000 like a chemistry experiment. There are typically quite wide variations in proportions for which the result which would be acceptable. So for the single loaf recipe if you varied any of the ingredients by +/- 25% you'd probably get an acceptable loaf of bread.

Second as Chris noted in his answer there are also procedural variations such as temperature and time that effect a recipe too.

So between the two there is some latitude in cooking.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.