I made this biscotti recipe yesterday - Fruity Christmas Biscotti. It contains plain flour, baking powder, mixed spice, golden caster sugar and eggs. The recipe also calls for raisins, dried cherries and nuts which I substituted dried cranberries and white chocolate chips for.

I love the recipe but it was a bit hard - I know biscotti is supposed to be hard but is there any way I can make it chewier or softer? I'm really looking for an ingredient to add, or to change the quantity of something that is already in the recipe rather than storage suggestions like putting an apple in the box with the biscuits.

7 Answers 7


My kids love a similar recipe, but they also like them softer. What I do is reducing the second baking time by half.

Be aware that the shelf life of the biscotti is also reduced! ... Not a problem in my case since they don't survive more than two days ...


Some history:

Though modern biscotti are associated with the Tuscan region of Italy, the popular Italian cookie traces its origins to Roman times. The word biscotto derives from “bis,” Latin for twice, and “coctum” or baked (which became “cotto,” or cooked). The Roman biscotti were more about convenience food for travelers rather than a pleasurable treat for leisurely diners. Unleavened, finger-shaped wafers were baked first to cook them, then a second time to completely dry them out, making them durable for travel and nourishment for the long journeys—Pliny boasted that they would be edible for centuries. Biscotti were a staple of the diet of the Roman Legions.

After the fall of the Roman Empire in 455 C.E, the country was repeatedly sacked by the Visigoths, the Vandals and others. The people did their best to survive; there was no culinary development. But with the Renaissance, cuisine also flowered. Biscotti re-emerged in Tuscany, credited to a Tuscan baker who served them with the local sweet wine. Their dry, crunchy texture was deemed to be the perfect medium to soak up the wine (and how much more flavorful than dunking a donut in coffee!). Centuries later, many still agree that dipping biscotti into Vin Santo is a perfect way to end a meal, or to while away an hour at a café.


I use my regular biscotti recipe, and then I make a simple powdered sugar icing (1/2 cup powdered sugar to 1- to 1 and half teaspoons water, liquor or juice, depending on the flavor of the biscotti). I drizzle the icing on the biscotti, and let the icing dry just until the outside is hard enough it won't smudge, then store them in an airtight container. The moisture of the icing is just enough to take the hard 'crispy crunch' off the biscotti, while still getting a nice texture. I think of it as the perfect biscotti... firm and toasty enough to dip in coffee, but if I take a bit without dunking, it doesn't hurt the roof of my mouth.


I love baking biscotti and trying those made by my friends. Over time, I have tinkered with a few biscotti recipes. There is a fine line between making biscotti that are crisp versus biscotti that are hard. In general, I got a better texture (not as hard) by reducing the quantity of flour. To make the biscotti crisp, I slice them quite thin (about 1/4 inch) using a serrated bread knife.


Less cooking time is important for a soft Biscotti...Also when mixing make a soft dough that must be handled with a large spoon..Drop the dough batter one spoon at a time to form a long line of dough batter..Bake for twenty five minutes,,Remove from oven..Let cool then cut on diagonal...They are done at this time..Dont return to oven for second bake on each side,Bake only one time..


To make cookies chewier, try more egg yolks. For that recipe I'd consider substituting one full egg for two egg yolks. This adds fat, which inhibits gluten development and increases chewiness.

In general, though, if I was going for soft I'd not make biscotti. I'd make drop cookies.

  • 1
    You mean substituting two egg yolks for one full egg, right?
    – Cascabel
    Nov 19, 2010 at 15:48
  • @Jefromi - yes, so it becomes 2 eggs and 2 egg yolks instead of 3 eggs in that recipe.
    – justkt
    Nov 19, 2010 at 15:58

Couldn't you just shorten the cooking time (or lower the temperature) for one or both of the baking stages?


I make Biscotti all the time and for a softer version just cook them less time..I bake the log for 15 minutes at 375 F then remove from oven let cool.then slice put back in oven for just five minutes standing up...Remove and you are done!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.