1

In my search for cultured butter I found butter that lists

culture distillate or lactic acid

as ingredients. Should these butters be considered cultured, even though the package nowhere actually says “cultured”?

  • 1
    Although in this case, it's likely shortcuts because of mass production (eg, adding vinegar to get a sour quality to make 'sourdough bread' vs. long, slow fermentation), for other cases of where meanings don't always perfectly align, see cooking.stackexchange.com/q/91691/67 – Joe Oct 31 '18 at 20:47
6

We're not all going to agree on a definition of cultured butter, so these answers are going to be subjective.

Culture distillate (https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfcfr/CFRSearch.cfm?fr=184.1848) and lactic acid are both used for flavoring. Is cultured butter butter that tastes a certain way, or butter that's been prepared a certain way?

How about a more common food: would you call it smoked salmon if it hadn't really been smoked, but only flavored with liquid smoke? There are reasonable arguments on both sides. Perhaps you consider smoked salmon to be a dish made with salmon that tastes smokey, regardless of how it's prepared. Perhaps you consider smoked salmon to be salmon that has been smoked, and you aren't really concerned with how it tastes.

Personally, I like to know what I'm eating (not just the flavor of what I'm eating). Calling something cultured butter suggests something about how it was made (fermented with live bacteria cultures), so calling cultured-flavored-butter "cultured" seems a bit dishonest for my taste.

  • clover sonoma, the maker of this butter, has yet to respond to my question. i have been led to believe that cultured butter results in a taste difference, therefore i am looking for them to claim their preparation method has produced a different product than just regular butter. they are not labeling this unsalted butter as cultured, or cultured-flavored, just listing it in the ingredients. it comes in a blue box. interestingly their salted butter (yellow box) in the same "line" has none of these ingredients. – yaya Nov 1 '18 at 6:16
  • now i notice all the boxes of butter from clover sonoma say SWEET CREAM butter, which would be a conflict in labeling if the butter was actually cultured. so i guess those added ingredients are flavoring agents rather than indications of method. i will just go buy butter that is clearly labeled cultured to satisfy my quest. – yaya Nov 1 '18 at 23:12
1

clover sonoma did answer me:"Our butters do not have added cultures. Adding the lactic acid (which itself is a product of fermentation) mimics the fermented flavors that culturing does. So it is closer to a cultured butter in flavor (as opposed to a sweet cream unsalted butter) but is not an authentic 'cultured butter." although they didnt address the "culture distillate" ingredient that is on the label its safe to just assume it doesnt make it cultured.
no wonder i liked the kerrygold unsweetened butter wrapped in gold foil! its only ingredient is "CULTURED PASTEURIZED CREAM".

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.