1

How does daube provencal differ from beef bourguignon?

7

The main differences:

  • Bourguignon is made with a red wine from the Burgundy (Bourgogne) region. Daube is a southern dish, from provence/languedoc, and would typically be made with a richer red (occasionally, and originally, white) wine from that region
  • Bourguignon is almost always garnished with small onions, carrots, mushroom and bacon, nothing else. Daube, being from the south, often has more mediterranean ingredients, such as garlic, tomatoes, larger onions, olives etc. and herbes de provence (vs a standard bouquet garni in a bourguignon)
  • Though bourguignon will use braising cuts of meat, it will typically just be cooked until the meat is tender, then served. Vegetables are often added at the end to keep their appearance and texture. Daube will typically user even cheaper cuts of meat with more sinew and collagen to break down e.g. shin, cheek, blade. It will be cooked for a long time, often with all the vegetables added from the start or half way through, allowing the meat to become very soft and break apart and thicken the braising liquid
  • Daube is traditionally cooked in a Daubiere, though what difference this makes to the end result is minimal

Effectively, bourguignon is perfectly braised meat in a rich onion-bacon-burgundy sauce, with some perfectly cooked mushrooms, carrots and baby onions as garnish.

Daube is a thick and hearty red wine and beef stew with meltingly soft meat and well cooked vegetables with mediterranean influenced flavours.

  • 1
    I disagree with the cheaper cuts of meat in daube, the same cuts work well in both and cooking times are just as long (my butcher recommended 4h vs the 2h I was doing before for bourguignon, he was right). As to removing the vegetables in bourguignon, I've never seen anything like this done, ever. The vegetables are not a garnish, they're an integral part of the stew. – user57361 Dec 28 '18 at 1:57
  • 1
    in reference to your second comments, a quick google found this four-magazine.com/recipes/a-recipe-by-michel-roux-jr . But you're correct that this is not necessarily the standard method. My point, i suppose, is that the vegetables are in the sauce, rather than being a part ofthe sauce as they are in a daube. It is a subtle difference, but many things are when it comes to regional dishes – canardgras Dec 28 '18 at 11:24
  • 1
    in reference to your first comment, nearly every source online suggests that a daube is cooked for a very long time - often from morning til evening, sometimes longer. bourguignon is never (traditionally) cooked for this long, thus the meat remains intact – canardgras Dec 28 '18 at 11:30
  • 1
    I am not looking at online sources, I'm referring to my (Berry) grandmother's bourguignon and my (Provence) roomate's grandmother's daube.. But while we both go a lot on their advice, we've also had lots of input from real cooks – user57361 Dec 28 '18 at 18:54
5

On a quick glance, one might easily confuse one with the other, but if you take a closer look, there are some subtle and not-so-subtle differences. You may want to consider that the method of “sear meat pieces in pot, cover with liquid (wine, in this case), let simmer until meat is tender” is a quite generic method of cooking certain pieces of meat.

But what about the differences?

  • Both dishes are today often made with beef, but unlike the bœf (=beef) bourguignon, a daube (=traditional cooking/braising pot) would often be made with wild boar, venison, mutton, whatever was available.

  • Both use the local wine, which would obviously give a slightly different flavor.

  • In a bœf bourguignon, the meat is often taken out once it’s done and the sauce reduced or thickened with a beurre manie, then served as cubes of meat in a sauce. The daube remains more liquid, more like a thick a soup. The very long cooking time (started in the morning, then left to simmer until dinner time) makes the meat very tender and ready to fall apart. It is traditionally eaten with a spoon and a slice of bread.
    (Looking at your tags, the tag “soup” is only justified for the daube, not the bœf bourguignon.)

  • The added vegetables differ, a bœf bourguignon often has mushrooms and bacon in addition to the carrot and onion, a daube shows a more Mediterranean flavor, with olives, tomatoes, garlic, other herbs.

  • Yes, on the whole. Let me just point out that bacon is not a perfect substitute, salt pork is much closer. – user57361 Dec 28 '18 at 1:59

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.