8

While using canned tuna to make salad, I remembered a Youtube video about sushi-grade tuna. If I recall correctly, the main criterion was if it contains parasites and that it's rather hard to find a clean fish, which makes them so highly priced. Especially the tail was heavily infested when they sliced up an example.

Now, since I have nothing better to do while eating, I thought I could ask how likely it is, that I'm currently eating some cooked tuna parasites?

  • 6
    If I was to guess, the likelyhood is high. BTW don't ever ask about hotdogs... ;-) – Steve Chambers Feb 18 at 20:26
  • @SteveChambers now you've made me curious ;) – sbo Feb 18 at 20:32
10

It is quite likely that it does contain them, yes.

A randomly chosen nonpaywalled study of Mediterannean tuna (DOI: 10.14411/fp.2014.011) says that

Overall, 84% of the gills examined harboured metazoan parasites.

Now these are the gills, not the meat in the tin, but it is unlikely that there will be much information on the meat itself:

The research on large tunas is hampered by the high value of fish; therefore, the studies on the use of parasites as tags consider mainly examination of gills, head and viscera, because of their limited (or null) commercial value

I don't know enough about fish parasite to tell you whether the 11 species found are all gill-only, but that sounds unlikely. Where there is an ecological niche, it will be filled. So, extrapolating from the gill parasite numbers to body parasite numbers doesn't sound too bad. And I am pretty certain that the people who prepare the fish don't have any method or reason to go remove the parasites from within the fish meat, just like apple sellers don't have a method to remove the worms from apples. So it sounds entirely believable that there are parasites in most cans of tuna, and if you eat enough of them, your chance of never eating a cooked parasite goes against zero.

  • Great answer, thanks a lot! However, I'll wait a bit before accepting it. – sbo Feb 18 at 21:51
  • 8
    Actually, in any animal it's more likely that parasites reside in the skin, hair, orifices or digestive tract and rarely in the flesh. You cannot extrapolate the presence or abundance of gill parasites to any other body part. – roetnig Feb 19 at 0:09
  • Parasites in the flesh of ocean fish is not rare at all. – aris Jul 15 at 1:58
5

TL;DR - Yes, the "monster soup" is pretty much a real thing.

To elaborate, I assume that we are talking about canned food in general, as there's nothing specific about canned tuna except that it's meat, which means it'll definitely go through Pressure Canning

  • The industrial canning process is all about Preservation by Sterilization i.e. putting the food in the can, sealing it, ensuring that it's leak proof (air tight) and then heating the under high pressure, high temperature (more than ~ 120°C / 248°F) so that all pathogens and bacteria in it die
  • Retort packaging e.g. Capri Sun also undergoes a similar process
  • Tetrapac is very similar to retort packaging except it relies on air tight / leak proof packaging and the food is only heat sterilized before packaging (part of the reason why orange juice in such packaging is always devoid of vitamin C)
  • As long as the container isn't damaged and within it's expiry date, it should be ideally safe for consumption

If you're concerned about The Dead Parasites

  • Yes, some parasites die & remain in the fluid as dead matter and keep floating in Brownian motion (click the link to watch the video)
  • Bacteria spores survive canning which remain dormant until the conditions become favorable again i.e. until you open the can (that's why they advise you to consume as soon as possible or refrigerate immediately)

PS:

  1. About the criterion you mentioned about quality of tuna / infested with parasites, I guess, that must be regarding the concern for transporting. Tuna fish is too big, too hard to catch & contain, and it is is expensive too. Tuna is usually captured & transported from Japan and if it's already infested with parasites, then it may not survive the journey and the dry ice doesn't help much as the fish is exposed. For the same reasons, some top chefs prefer (small) fishes shipped alive, Tuna fish is too big for that.

  2. I became familiar with the Victorian age fantasy word The monster Soup while watching Manu Prakash's Foldscope. The word is a reference to the microbes present in water observed under a microscope.

  3. Boiled Dirty Water under the Microscope - This video is cool. I'd definitely recommend watching.

4

Probably only just the "dead" ones, due to the rigors of the canning process -- https://www.quora.com/Does-canned-tuna-have-parasites

0

I bought fresh tuna for my cats today for the first time. It was cut into cubes and packed upon my request. While I was dividing the tuna pieces for freezing, I was disgusted to see white worms in the flesh. Yuck!!!

Apparently, they were in the belly part, embedded in the flesh. I was surprised to find a misleading advice on Livestrong that tuna is an exception to fish carrying parasites. I found at least 10-15 worms in 1 kg tuna. I wish I had clicked a picture to upload.

  • If you read the livestrong link I added - it says specifically to get sushi grade tuna. It does not say that they will be free of parasites, just less likely, if you get sushi tuna. Also note that freezing will kill the parasites, and I doubt that your cats will care. – bob1 Jul 18 at 16:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.