I was reading comments about oil or no oil. I use butter, but when cooking a 50/50 white/wholemeal loaf it is so soft its like cotton wool and nearly impossible to cut. Any ideas how get the loaf a bit firmer


1 Answer 1


For a firm loaf you want more gluten development. So:

  • Cut out the fat: it impedes the reactions forming gluten.

  • Make sure your yeast or sour-dough starter is active, or use instant yeast (very reliable in my experience): the carbon dioxide created as a by-product of fermentation promotes gluten development.

  • Use stronger (that is, higher protein) white flour rather than AP flour

  • Work the dough thoroughly: it is hard to overknead by hand. Several short kneads can be more effective than one long knead.

  • Try giving the dough a long rest, for instance overnight in a fridge.

  • Avoid granary flours or seeds with sharp edges: these cut the developing gluten network and make for a weaker loaf.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.