I have just made a pastie in a pie dish using S.Burt's recipe Can I substitute olive oil for butter/shortening in pie crust?. It was really delicious but has no strength. I used rice oil and lite milk and did not rest the pastry. I used plain all purpose 9.7% protein flour. Can anyone advise how to get a stronger pastry so that the pastie is contained by the pastry and doesn't need a pie dish?

  • 1
    ... rice oil? I'm not familiar with that ingredient, could it have properties that might be a factor?
    – Megha
    Jun 13, 2018 at 6:54
  • I'm not sure, it is bland and has a high smoke point.And I'm trying to avoid animal fats from a healthy heart perspective. Jun 13, 2018 at 8:24
  • 1
    @Megha there isn't anything special about rice oil, it is highly refined and behaves virtually identical to other stuff labeled "vegetable oil".
    – rumtscho
    Jun 14, 2018 at 14:06
  • I like to add bacon fat to my pancakes instead of butter, my kids still don’t know why dads pancakes are so delicious lol Jul 15, 2018 at 3:20
  • Also, don't forget that butter is only 75% fat and 25% water/milk solids. So if you change to a pure fat, reduce it to 75% and add some water or milk to compensate. Jul 16, 2018 at 18:31

2 Answers 2


Traditional Cornish Pasty pastry is made with 1 part strong bread flour, 1/4 part each of butter and lard, about 1/3 part water, and about 1% of the flour's weight in salt. The pastry is worked quite hard, almost like a bread dough, and left to rest for a good hour. The resulting pastry is leathery enough to withstand a miner's pocket, faintly crisp on the outside, (with an egg-wash), and slightly gooey where it meets the filling ingredients, which are introduced raw, and cooked in the pastry.

Doing the sums, that's about 450g of fat to a kilo of flour,and 380g of water. Bread flour is 12-15% protein, higher than yours. The stronger your flour mixture, the more pliable the result.. the more oil, the more prone to crumbling (pure oil> shortbread.. pure water>something like a salt crust which it might take a hammer to break)

If I was experimenting with oils, I would combine the oil with the flour first, (probably in a food processor - it doesn't matter if it's overworked) and introduce the water slowly, until a coherent ball is formed, bearing in mind the paste will become more pliable after resting.

For a Cornish Pasty, the paste is rolled quite thick, about 5mm, cut with a dinner-plate as a guide, back half flopped over the pin to be filled, then folded over, and crimped.

Forgive me if I've misunderstood what you mean by 'Pasty' .. but then, I come from that part of the world.. :) But it might, anyway, be an informative parallel to the kind of pasty you're aiming for.


Mix only the milk with some of the flour and knead like making a bread dough. Next, roll the dough ito a flat sheet.

Mix the rest of the flour with the oil and spread the mixture on the sheet. Roll up the sheet like a jelly roll and then into a coil. Roll flat the coil and use it as your pastry for foldovers or empanadas.

This link will demonstrate in detail: Huaiyang Chinese Pastry

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.