I am trying to make a multigrain/white blended bread, I want to break away from using a breadmaker and manually mix it.

My recipe:

  • 1 package (1/4 ounce - 1.5us tsp) active dry yeast (my previous attempts did not rise very much, suspected old yeast - new yeast was purchased, confirmed active)
  • 2-1/4 cups warm water (110° to 115°) (water verified this temperature range with thermometer before mixing begins. any extra added is less than 15ml and also the same temp)
  • 3 tablespoons sugar
  • 2 tsp salt
  • 2 tablespoons butter
  • 6-1/4 to 6-3/4 cups flour (using 2 cups of multigrain bread flour, 4 cups all purpose white flour)


Yeast is activated and dissolved in sugar water mixture before other ingredients are added. After adding, as per the above recipe I knead it for 10 minutes on a floured surface. Initial rising time is 30-45 mins or until doubled, dough is punched down and then shaped into loaves and divided into lightly greased breadpans. secondary rising time 30 mins or until doubled, placed into 350F oven for 30-40 mins or until lightly browned bread sounds 'hollow' when tapped.


  • What should the dough look/feel like when it's ready? (can anyone post me a picture of the targeted product?)
  • What is overkneading?
  • Is the recipe alright?
  • Do you have additional steps to follow?

My background: I am a 260lb x-military veteran who regularly does 1000 pushups every 3 days, avg bench is 300lbs for several full sets, overhead press and pulls are roughly the same weights.

The point of me saying this - someone suggested I have kneaded the bread too much and too strongly.

Previous loaves were hard and did not rise very much.

Please offer this rookie some advice.

  • Have you used the same recipe in a breadmaker before? If yes, how did it turn out?
    – Stephie
    Commented Mar 2, 2017 at 19:01
  • Some more questions: a) can we see a picture of your bread? b) did you determine rises by time or volume?
    – Stephie
    Commented Mar 2, 2017 at 19:17
  • I used a recipe that came with the breadmaker first - seemed a little too 'wet' on the interior, and the bread did not rise very much, loaves were undersized as well. This recipe presented was taken from literally the first book I picked up - loaves produced have been hard. I used time as a loose guide but went by how much volume increased. Volume increase was very slow (over 1.5hr rise time - it did rise but after a while it just kind of stopped, did not double as it was supposed to.) working on the pictures.
    – Chris
    Commented Mar 2, 2017 at 19:18
  • Throw a couple more questions out, are you at altitude? Do you have especially hard water or heavily chlorinated?
    – dlb
    Commented Mar 2, 2017 at 19:36
  • my city is approx 1,045 m above sealevel, water hardness is: mg/L CaCO 3 - 228, 15.9 grains/gal, water is considered 'hard'
    – Chris
    Commented Mar 2, 2017 at 19:41

4 Answers 4


There can be a lot of things happening here, but I will start with some first ideas.

  1. You are not overkneading. Overkneading is not about raw strength. It doesn't happen per hand, not in 10 minutes (actually, it doesn't happen in the mixer within 10 minutes either). Whatever your problems are, overkneading is very unlikely to be one of them. If it were, you would notice a pronounced change from sticky through supple to weirdly-noncohesive.

  2. You are killing most of your yeast off. 110 to 115 F is not "warm" water when it comes to yeast, it is scalding. If you absolutely need quick rising times, use water at 90 F, +-5. Room temperature water (70 F +-10) will produce better tasting bread, and also has a larger margin for error.

  3. Forget the time directions for rising and really go with "until doubled". Proof in a measuring container, or at least in a square or cylindrical one where you can mark the initial level. "Just kinda stopped" should not happen before doubling, if the yeast is well and alive.

  4. The problem is not in the proportions of your recipe. They are pretty much middle of the road, assuming that you are really following them and not mismeasuring somehow. If you think it is a measuring issue, weigh the ingredients, that's not nearly as error-prone as baking by volume.

  5. A somewhat far-fetched idea would be that you beat too much flour from the mat into the dough during kneading. My quick calculation shows that you would have to beat in well over 150 g of flour before it starts getting unpleasantly hard, but if you want to avoid this source of error, knead without additional flour (just disregard the sticking).

  6. Preheat your oven. If you have a pizza stone or some other good thermal mass, use it.

  7. If you really have that big problems, try simple white bread first. After you have mastered that, you can get to multigrain loaves. They typically don't rise as much as white bread, and are more difficult to get right.

  • Is the hard water of any concern to you? I know that there are degrees of "hardness" that can affect rising.
    – Catija
    Commented Mar 2, 2017 at 20:03
  • Thank you very much, very appreciated. You got me at number 5! I definitely put too much flour in, as I had this idea in my head that it shouldn't be sticky at all, ever. oh god what have I done! Will try another loaf keeping your advice in mind.
    – Chris
    Commented Mar 2, 2017 at 20:04
  • @Catija not within any standard range of hardness. If the OP has something off the charts, then I don't know. But I have water which leaves scale on pitchers after several days at room temperature, and that's not a problem for bread. Slight differences in hardness might matter to artisan bakers who want to perfect every detail, but it is not an obstacle to making decent bread by home standards.
    – rumtscho
    Commented Mar 2, 2017 at 20:07
  • @Chris yeah, I'm not a big bread baker (yet) but I was surprised to learn that there are some doughs that start out very sticky but as you knead them, they will often come together into lovely doughs. Best of luck!
    – Catija
    Commented Mar 2, 2017 at 20:08
  • You are right at the edge of considered high altitude for bread, but high altitude would tend to over-rise or rise fast, not what you are getting. I think rumtscho may be getting you on course though, a bit cooler water to insure you don't shock the yeast and a bit less added flour on next try may help. Baking floor bricks instead of loafs is no fun, as I also know from experience. You are not alone.
    – dlb
    Commented Mar 2, 2017 at 20:29

I'm an experienced bread baker.

  1. That's not enough yeast for the amount of flour; you need a scant Tablespoon.

  2. Assuming your yeast is fresh, the temperature you mentioned is at the edge of killing yeast.

  3. I recommend using instant yeast. You don't need to proof; you just add it to the flour and skip the proofing stage with its water and sugar. You can buy a whole pound for about $3-4 (much cheaper). Keep some in your refrigerator and freeze the rest.

  4. There's no way you're overkneading.

  5. Flour varies in its moisture content. You may have to add or subtract some water until it feels elastic and doesn't stick to your mixing bowl or fingers. This takes some experience to recognize how it should feel.

  6. To test whether the bread has risen enough: when the dough starts looking doubled and plump, press two of your fingertips into the bread. If the holes start to fill in, the bread is not overproofed. If the holes remain, the bread is overproofed and will collapse in the oven.

  7. Slashing the dough with a serrated knife or razor blade right before placing in oven can help improve ovenspring.

  8. Your bread is done when you hear a thump when you tap the bottom with your finger, and the interior temperature is 200-205F. An instant-read thermometer is handy.

  9. For most-developed flavor, cool on a rack for 20 minutes (it's the law in France!).

  10. More advice upon request.


  • thank you for taking your time to give me this advice, my bread will be far from what regular adepts and experts consider good, but at the very least it will be decent for a rookie like me. (and at less than 1$ per loaf, it just beats storebought by far) So far it seems my latest creation has not fallen - though I will conduct the proofing test from now on. Your notes regarding yeast will be recorded, thank you. Also, a sidequestion, how does one post a picture? Thanks again, your hints and advice are quite welcome indeed.
    – Chris
    Commented Mar 2, 2017 at 23:56
  • Click on the image icon above your posting. After that, it's pretty self-explanatory.
    – Larry G.
    Commented Mar 3, 2017 at 0:24
  • I agree with Alaska below. Try using bread flour instead of AP flour. It has more protein and can make stronger gluten. The multigrain mixture has sharp edges and can cut gluten strands, so the stronger the gluten the better. Until you get lots of experience, it's usually best to keep whole wheat or multigrain mixtures under a 50% ratio (which your recipe does).
    – Larry G.
    Commented Mar 3, 2017 at 3:56
  • Noted, I will be archiving this information on my local PC to preserve this good data.
    – Chris
    Commented Mar 3, 2017 at 4:03
  • 1
    I strongly disagree with your first point. You might be an experienced baker, but there is absolutely no reason to increase the yeast amount, OP simply needs to adapt rising times. Taste-wise, less yeast gives better results because the yeast taste is less dominant and other flavour components have time to develop during longer resting phases.
    – Stephie
    Commented Mar 3, 2017 at 6:50


After taking advice to stick to all purpose flour, yeast age, appropriate temperatures and decreasing amount of flour used, and no fear of overkneading anymore; the change was palpable. Here are before and after pictures:


I've got a long way to go but I'm closer to the right track this time. Fluffy loaf, with a nice texture. Density is passable - edible at least. hahaha. Once I've increased my skill with all purpose flour, I'll graduate into multigrain, and hopefully I won't have to bother you guys too much more.

  • Chris. it is possible/probable that you are not getting enough strength through gluten formation because you are using an AP flour in combination with WW flour. AP flour is usable for some breads but not optimal and in combination with a low protein WW flour you while find it difficult to achieve enough gluten formation to have the strength to hold a good shape. Switch to a good quality bread flour and depending on how much WW flour you use you could add a small amount of high protein flour. when kneading learn how to do a window pane test to check if you sufficient gluten development.
    – Alaska Man
    Commented Mar 3, 2017 at 1:49
  • its entirely possible. I will explore this in further detail when re-integrating WW flours into the mixture, thank you for the information.
    – Chris
    Commented Mar 3, 2017 at 3:37
  • @Chris, you are more than welcome to "bother" us and I'm happy for you that you have gotten so much better results! You might want to browse other questions tagged "bread
    – Stephie
    Commented Mar 3, 2017 at 19:04

To address your first question, I snapped a few pictures of what will be breakfast buns tomorrow. Note that I used my mixer and a slightly wetter dough, but the pattern stays the same.

A standard bread / yeast dough recipe forms in stages. First the wet and the dry ingredients are just mixed. Some dry pockets might remain and the overall appearance is very lumpy or shaggy:

enter image description here

Then, you get a more uniform distribution, but still not a smooth dough:

enter image description here

But after a while, you'll notice the dough getting very elastic, smooth and uniform in texture. At that point, the stickiness disappears as well.

enter image description here

And I mean elastic:

enter image description here

My great-aunt used to say that

A finished dough will leave your hands and bowl clean.1

This means the gluten strands are well-developed and hold together - and will be able to both keep your loaf together during rising and baking and trap the steam inside to give your bread a nice, light texture. A windowpane test will show you a thin, even and slightly translucent dough.

Overkneading means you have kneaded the dough so long that the gluten strands were "torn". That's an irreversible process, but very unlikely to happen if you knead by hand. It happens if you keep kneading after you have reached the "well kneaded" stage. My gut feeling is that the fear of overkneading goes back to the time when stand mixers made their debut in kitchens and bakeries: Machine kneading is usually a lot faster than kneading by hand. So if one used a recipe that required 20 or more minutes of manual kneading and let the machine run for the same time (not watching the dough, just going by the timer), chances were high that the batch would be ruined due to overkneading.

Your recipe uses rather average ratios, I see no need to adjust anything. Of course many bakers go by the "wetter is better" rule, but that produces another type of bread. For a standard sandwich loaf, it's fine.

Being careful with your yeast has been discussed before - rather go for just tepid water and proof a bit longer before scalding your yeast. Similar rules apply for letting the dough rise in too warm environements. Not only can the yeast and the dough texture suffer, but yeast that rises at the upper edge of the temperature range creates more unpleasant by-tastes than yeast in the middle or lower range. The dough in the pictures above is proofing for ten hours in the fridge.

Also note that you should be careful about the amout of flour you use during kneading and shaping. If you have a recipe that gives a range for the amount of flour, it's often advisable to use the lower amount in the dough and keep the remainder for your work surface. This ensures that you don't work too much flour into the dough. (Unless the recipe specifies extra flour for dusting.)

If you come across a somewhat soft and wet dough that is very prone to sticking, switch your kneading technique instead of adding flour: this video gives you a good technique and you can also see how the dough gets more and more smooth, elastic and loses the stickiness. It's also a bit of a workout for the baker.

1 She was talking about doughs like yours. For high-hydration recipes there will be some stickiness.

  • thank you for the in-depth analysis. that brings the puzzle together, as my successful loaves had dough similar in texture coming out of the mixing bowl, and I also attempted a new recipe which had a high moisture %, and it baked very well and tasted great. So I feel in my first experiments, the dough was under-kneaded, low moisture content, mostly dead yeast, and too much flour when dusting as well. That french method for kneading is definitely more my style - greatly appreciate that source, as it removes incorrect information from my repertoire.
    – Chris
    Commented Mar 6, 2017 at 23:21

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.