I made chocolate eclairs, my second attempt copying exactly from Laura in the Kitchen on YouTube (full recipe here), and the pastry was not all well creamed and looked oily as I placed in oven. It looked as though it was frying.

Please can you kindly explain what I did wrong? I feel so frustrated as they baked over 30 minutes and came out rock hard, but completely moist in the middle. Just wasted so many ingredients, eggs and milk and flour and butter.

  • Sorry, but "Laura's kitchen on Youtube" is somewhat vague - could you please at least give a link or, even better, post the recipe + instructions? We are eager to help but we prefer giving answers over detective work on the Internet to understand the question.
    – Stephie
    Jul 11, 2015 at 15:16
  • 1
    Just because you are new here, some help: Do you mean this video?
    – Stephie
    Jul 11, 2015 at 15:27
  • If that's it, this should be the full recipe, so you don't have to watch a video: laurainthekitchen.com/recipes/eclairs
    – Cascabel
    Jul 11, 2015 at 17:22
  • 1
    What is your baking experience level? Not that experienced bakers can't fail but there's something you learn with experience at making simpler things. Without knowing what you did, we can't possibly know what went wrong. Did you follow the *recipe exactly? Did you complete each step?
    – Catija
    Jul 11, 2015 at 17:34
  • 1
    And what do you mean by wasting milk? It doesn't go in the batter and the custard can be used otherwise, no problem. Or what did you do with the milk?
    – Stephie
    Jul 11, 2015 at 21:16

1 Answer 1


As the commenters have already said, it's hard to know exactly what happened from the information you've given but I'm going to try to give some direction.

First, I think the key is in this statement: "the pastry was not all well creamed and looked oily as I placed in oven".

This sounds like either the oil (butter, in this case) separated out from the batter, or it wasn't well-mixed to begin with. Let's assume that you mixed it thoroughly to begin with until it seemed like a creamy, smooth batter and everything seemed well-incorporated.

So, what happened? I'm guessing that you left the eclairs-to-be resting on the pans for a while, maybe while you were piping out the rest of them.

If you let the batter sit for a while, oil can start to separate out, especially if your kitchen is pretty warm (which they can be, in summer when boiling water on the stove and pre-heating the oven). This shouldn't happen immediately, but I think it would explain what happened.

Next time, make sure everything is ready and laid out before you start. Start to pre-heat the oven before you start boiling the water. Once you start piping, move quickly, and if possible, work in a cooler part of the kitchen. Pop the trays directly into the oven as soon as you finish piping them all out.

There's a second thing you said that I think is significant. You said that the outside was rock-hard but the inside was too moist. I think the excess moisture is from steam.

It is normal for the eclair to have a bit of a crust to it (not rock-hard, of course, but there will be a crust) and this traps steam inside. You need to break a hole through the crust to let the steam out, and my guess is that either you may have missed this step, or the hole you made wasn't big enough.

BTW, it is also possible to have something get too hard and still be raw in the middle if you cook for too long at too low a temperature (it dries out instead of cooking) but you said you cooked for 30 minutes and that matches the recipe timing, so I don't think that was your problem here. But if you have a lot of problems with things not taking the right amount of time when you bake, you might want to invest in an oven thermometer and see if your oven is heating to the temperatures you expect. Not all recipes are very finicky about exact temperatures but some are.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.