My wife helps organize a vegetarian community kitchen. She recently had a request for tiramisu-like dessert but there are a number of restrictions:

  • The time frame of the kitchen means they only have two hours to prepare it before eating (including chilling)
  • They cannot use raw eggs
  • No alcohol
  • No cheese (the woman requesting doesn't eat cheese) but other dairy is okay

My wife would like to try to accommodate the request if possible.

She was thinking replace the traditional mascarpone custard with a mixture of Greek yoghurt and whipped cream (do you think the whipped cream needs to be stabilized with agar agar?).

Does this sound workable (she has never tried this before and is not a professional chef)? If not, is there a better plan, or does this request sound like an impossibility?

  • I'm wondering if you can find a tiramisu-flavored instant pudding.
    – Marti
    Commented Jan 15, 2014 at 15:28
  • I will take a t-bone... but skip the cow!
    – blankip
    Commented Nov 5, 2015 at 18:08

3 Answers 3


I think that it is doable, if the restriction doesn't require the dessert to be exactly a tiramisu.

Many dairy-based cremes are interchangeable, similar in texture, and require no eggs at all. The alcohol in some tiramisu versions can be safely left out. The short time is the worst restriction. Thickeners like agar agar may not set in the short time.

You should start with buying prepared lady fingers, as you can't bake them so quickly, and it is probably too much effort anyway. You can use any tiramisu recipe for the moistening liquid; if it includes alcohol, just leave it out. You can add a few drops of alcohol-free rum essence if it called for rum or another hard alcohol, or a fruit aroma if it called for a fruit liqueur. If it only specified coffee liqueur, leave out the liqueur but use normal coffee. You might want to use instant coffee dissolved in water instead of just-brewed espresso, because hot coffee will interfere with the short chilling time. Then you need the dairy creme, and you can finish with the traditional cocoa powder.

For the dairy creme, you have to choose one which will hold its shape without thickeners. You can add agar agar or carrageenan or the calcium-sensitive type of pectin, but don't trust them to turn a runny mass into a firm one, the time is too short. Use them as an insurance, and hoping that you will get something which gives some resistance to being cut or chewed, as opposed to being just scoopable. Whipped cream together with Greek yogurt is not a bad idea; other cultured milk products can work too, if they are on the firmer side. I have had similar desserts made with just schmand as the filling, but they stayed overnight so some whey could diffuse into the non-syruped cookies, making the cookies softer and the schmand drier. If you have access to the type of modified starch which will thicken without having to cook (for example sold as "cream stiffener", but also as a cream replacement product to be whipped with milk), using some of it may help. Don't use liquid sweeteners like corn syrup or honey, stay with sugar, and separate the whey from the yogurt to get a firmer result.

Another way would be to use a starch thickened pudding instead of a custard. This is a more common substitute, but normal starch has to be cooked to a boil, and will require longer chilling. You may be able to pull it off, if you make the whole dessert rather flat and wide, use a pre-chilled vessel and dip the ladyfingers into cold liquid, and then put the poured dessert into a freezer for a quick chilling. It will need quick work (so lots of time remains for chilling) and frequent attention so it can chill without freezing. The first version is probably less stress.

Whichever you choose, such a major recipe change is not easy. Make a prototype at home before you cook it for a crowd, so you can catch the major problems in an early version and relaxed environment, and then you will know if it is doable for sure.

  • 2
    Iota carrageenan sets pretty quickly, starting at temperatures as high as 70° C (basically, almost instantly, you have to keep it on the heat to stop it from setting). 2 hours is plenty of time. Agar needs to get down to almost room temperature so that's not a good bet.
    – Aaronut
    Commented Jan 15, 2014 at 2:03
  • 1
    Coffee should serve in lieu of alcohol; and whipped cream should require no thickeners at all.
    – SAJ14SAJ
    Commented Jan 15, 2014 at 14:33
  • To avoid the raw eggs, you could do a creme anglaise as well (perhaps even with the espresso added to it?). It only takes a few minutes to prepare. You could actually even fold whipped cream into that to get a texture similar to whipped mascarpone.
    – SourDoh
    Commented Jan 15, 2014 at 15:51

First, being that the kitchen is vegetarian, it would be optimal to make the recipe vegan. Many vegetarians actually prefer vegan.

Perhaps you could make a modern tiramisu without the ladyfingers, as a layered cake? This would be faster.

Below is a tiramisu cupcake recipe I made that was fantastic. You could easily use it to make the layered tiramisu cake. In place of the amaretto, you can use agave syrup + a little water + almond extract.


If you still desire a mascarpone substitute--I'd use Follow Your Heart brand vegan cream cheese and vegan sour cream whipped with vanilla and powdered sugar and a little bit of cornstarch. Adding almond milk creamer would improve the taste as well. Greek yogurt is pretty wet, so I'm not sure how that would work out. I have, however, used Greek-style almond milk yogurt successfully--but that's hard to find in many places.

Edit: I found this recipe that looks promising: http://veggywood.com/2010/07/19/vegan-tiramisu-finally/

One benefit of vegan creams and fillings is that they're so easily adjustable, and the consistencies are reliable--what comes out of the package is what will result. You don't have to mess around with whipping creams and stabilizing and whatnot. I say, play around with some of the non-cheese & nondairy ingredients mentioned in this thread. Come up with a creamy filling that you enjoy. What you're striving for is a dessert with amazing taste and texture, not one that is exactly like traditional tiramisu. They will love it. :)

  • 2
    "First, being that the kitchen is vegetarian, it would be optimal to make the recipe vegan. Many vegetarians actually prefer vegan." Um... no. That's a completely and utterly unfounded statement.
    – Catija
    Commented Nov 5, 2015 at 22:15

You might want look into "aquafaba" techniques (using legume stocks as an egg alternative that can be whipped stiff) for some of the layers, these hadn't been discovered/publicly documented at the time the original question was asked.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.